Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
2It was offside and a dive and 100% wrong, i think the conversation between the pair of clowns admitting they didn't have a clue on motd shows how these poor decisions come about
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
3It was onside and not a dive and 100% correct.
Just surprised noone has started a petition to get the game replayed.
It's like the Brexit referendum mark 2.
Just surprised noone has started a petition to get the game replayed.
It's like the Brexit referendum mark 2.
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
4I have not had the benefit of watching replays but my distinct impression on seeing this incident live was that Kane deliberately collided with the Liverpool player. It was a clear dive and I was surprised when the referee awarded a penalty. I also thought he was offside. Kane went down in my estimation last night. I was very disappointed in him. If he performs that trick against County in the unlikely event that he plays on Wednesday we should rightly be angry.
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
5TBWAH wrote:It was onside and not a dive and 100% correct.
Just surprised noone has started a petition to get the game replayed.
It's like the Brexit referendum mark 2.
Not a dive? I'm sure happy Harry agrees with you. 'I felt contact and I went down'. Hmmmm.
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
6I don't disagree but.G Guest wrote:I have not had the benefit of watching replays but my distinct impression on seeing this incident live was that Kane deliberately collided with the Liverpool player. It was a clear dive and I was surprised when the referee awarded a penalty. I also thought he was offside. Kane went down in my estimation last night. I was very disappointed in him. If he performs that trick against County in the unlikely event that he plays on Wednesday we should rightly be angry.
0-0 in the last minute and a County player takes a dive, Labadie puts it away and we're in round 5.
Do you still take the moral high ground then? Not a trick question, I really don't know how I'd feel.
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
7Those were the exact words Michael Owen used after "winning" a penalty for England against Argentina in the World Cup.pembsexile wrote:TBWAH wrote:It was onside and not a dive and 100% correct.
Just surprised noone has started a petition to get the game replayed.
It's like the Brexit referendum mark 2.
Not a dive? I'm sure happy Harry agrees with you. 'I felt contact and I went down'. Hmmmm.
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
9So not a penalty then?Rjwebby2811 wrote:It was a penalty but he was offside
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
10Yeah should of been flagged offside but I can't stand Liverpool so happy it stooddaftasfxxx wrote:So not a penalty then?Rjwebby2811 wrote:It was a penalty but he was offside
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
11Simple rule when judging a cheat
Legs taken from under you = penalty
Felt a touch = diving cheat
Simples
Legs taken from under you = penalty
Felt a touch = diving cheat
Simples
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
12If you look at it , both of Karius' hands are planted flat to the ground . He did everything he could to avoid committing the foul .
Kane's knee clipped the keepers elbow ever so slightly and he makes the most of it .
I can never understand how "winning a penalty" has any place in the game ?
It's "cheating" in my eyes .... whoever team you support .
I like Kane and I like the way Tottenham generally play , but I thought they conned everyone yesterday with both penalty decisions .
Thought they deserved their point for the draw , but not in the manner they achieved it .
Anyway ..... let's give them a go on Wednesday !
Create a noise , get in their faces and at least make a game of it !
Amber Army !!!!!
Kane's knee clipped the keepers elbow ever so slightly and he makes the most of it .
I can never understand how "winning a penalty" has any place in the game ?
It's "cheating" in my eyes .... whoever team you support .
I like Kane and I like the way Tottenham generally play , but I thought they conned everyone yesterday with both penalty decisions .
Thought they deserved their point for the draw , but not in the manner they achieved it .
Anyway ..... let's give them a go on Wednesday !
Create a noise , get in their faces and at least make a game of it !
Amber Army !!!!!
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
13Excellent post, couldn't agree moreCorpaboy wrote:If you look at it , both of Karius' hands are planted flat to the ground . He did everything he could to avoid committing the foul .
Kane's knee clipped the keepers elbow ever so slightly and he makes the most of it .
I can never understand how "winning a penalty" has any place in the game ?
It's "cheating" in my eyes .... whoever team you support .
I like Kane and I like the way Tottenham generally play , but I thought they conned everyone yesterday with both penalty decisions .
Thought they deserved their point for the draw , but not in the manner they achieved it .
Anyway ..... let's give them a go on Wednesday !
Create a noise , get in their faces and at least make a game of it !
Amber Army !!!!!
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
14Ball took a touch off Liverpool player so onside.
Kane went down easily but there was contact so not a dive.
Fine margins but penalty was correctly awarded.
Kane went down easily but there was contact so not a dive.
Fine margins but penalty was correctly awarded.
Re: Harry Kane's Penalty Right or wrong?
15I thought that aspect of offside went out about twenty years ago. When the ball was played forward by a Tottenham player, Kane was beyond the last defender - offside.Valley Exile wrote:Ball took a touch off Liverpool player so onside.
Kane went down easily but there was contact so not a dive.
Fine margins but penalty was correctly awarded.
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: Baladabadi, Lord Tredegar's Parrot, OLDCROMWELLIAN, Stow Hill Sid