Butler Out

Butler Out

1 by Willthiswork

https://www.southwalesargus.co.uk/sport ... ster-city/

Dan Butler suspended for game v Leicester due to two yellow cards.

New FA rule means that cards only count in same competition.

Re: Butler Out

2 by UPTHEPORT

That's a big blow

Re: Butler Out

3 by Blackandamber

His booking against Wrexham was so unnecessary. Why get involved when the ref had already sent off the Wrexham player. I agree with Mike Flynn though that the new rule favours the tier 1 and 2 clubs who only enter the FA Cup at round 3 so can't have any players banned due to 2 yellow cards.

Re: Butler Out

4 by UPTHEPORT

Blackandamber wrote:His booking against Wrexham was so unnecessary. Why get involved when the ref had already sent off the Wrexham player. I agree with Mike Flynn though that the new rule favours the tier 1 and 2 clubs who only enter the FA Cup at round 3 so can't have any players banned due to 2 yellow cards.

Then non league Clubs could say the same thing
Over tier 3 and 4 then tier 5 etc

Re: Butler Out

5 by Exile 1976

UPTHEPORT wrote:
Blackandamber wrote:His booking against Wrexham was so unnecessary. Why get involved when the ref had already sent off the Wrexham player. I agree with Mike Flynn though that the new rule favours the tier 1 and 2 clubs who only enter the FA Cup at round 3 so can't have any players banned due to 2 yellow cards.

Then non league Clubs could say the same thing
Over tier 3 and 4 then tier 5 etc

And they’d be right

Re: Butler Out

6 by UPTHEPORT

Exile 1976 wrote:
UPTHEPORT wrote:
Blackandamber wrote:His booking against Wrexham was so unnecessary. Why get involved when the ref had already sent off the Wrexham player. I agree with Mike Flynn though that the new rule favours the tier 1 and 2 clubs who only enter the FA Cup at round 3 so can't have any players banned due to 2 yellow cards.

Then non league Clubs could say the same thing
Over tier 3 and 4 then tier 5 etc

And they’d be right

I hope the Club/ Flynny has given him a bolloxin stupid card no need to get involved.

The Ref delt with it straight away Red was shown within 2 seconds

Re: Butler Out

7 by Willthiswork

The cards should be reset at the 1st round and 3rd round proper.

Re: Butler Out

8 by Amberexile

Exile 1976 wrote:
UPTHEPORT wrote:
Blackandamber wrote:His booking against Wrexham was so unnecessary. Why get involved when the ref had already sent off the Wrexham player. I agree with Mike Flynn though that the new rule favours the tier 1 and 2 clubs who only enter the FA Cup at round 3 so can't have any players banned due to 2 yellow cards.

Then non league Clubs could say the same thing
Over tier 3 and 4 then tier 5 etc

And they’d be right

Didn't Wrexham have a player suspended against us for this?

Re: Butler Out

9 by Exile 1976

Amberexile wrote:
Exile 1976 wrote:
UPTHEPORT wrote:

Then non league Clubs could say the same thing
Over tier 3 and 4 then tier 5 etc

And they’d be right
Didn't Wrexham have a player suspended against us for this?

I don’t know mate, but if they did that’s ridiculous. Terrible rule.

Re: Butler Out

10 by Amberexile

Exile 1976 wrote:
Amberexile wrote: Didn't Wrexham have a player suspended against us for this?

I don’t know mate, but if they did that’s ridiculous. Terrible rule.

I've just looked it up, Brad Walker was booked in the original tie against us up there so missed the replay due to suspension.
It was mentioned in the Argus which is why it must have stuck in my mind.
Agree it is a terrible rule clearly designed to favour the bigger clubs.

Re: Butler Out

11 by Stan A. Einstein

Exile 1976 wrote:
UPTHEPORT wrote:

Then non league Clubs could say the same thing
Over tier 3 and 4 then tier 5 etc

And they’d be right

Nice to see a bit of logical thinking on this board.

Re: Butler Out

12 by Percy plunkett

Man C,Liverpool etc get a player booked in R3/4, then he gets booked in semi,he misses Final.Pep and Klopp will soon moan then.They have not noticed the rule change yet.

Re: Butler Out

13 by Fourthousand

Percy plunkett wrote:Man C,Liverpool etc get a player booked in R3/4, then he gets booked in semi,he misses Final.Pep and Klopp will soon moan then.They have not noticed the rule change yet.

Probably replace him with a 1st team player.

Re: Butler Out

14 by Cornish Exile

UPTHEPORT wrote:That's a big blow

Mickey Demetriou has played left back/wing back for most of his career prior to joining County. Might even be an improvement.

Re: Butler Out

15 by Exile 1976

Got Pring to play there.

Connect with your social network account

Display posts from previous

Sort by