Seeing as it always causes a conversation with people having different opinions, heres mine...

Townsend 7
Shepard 7
Cooper 8
Dolan 8
Demetriou 7
Haynes 8
Labadie 6
Sheehan 8
Twine 8
Abraham's 7
Amond 8

I would agree with those, maybe Shep deserves an 8 tho'?

Willthiswork wrote:I would agree with those, maybe Shep deserves an 8 tho'?

He was a 6 up until the last 15 mins!!

SULLY34 wrote:

Willthiswork wrote:I would agree with those, maybe Shep deserves an 8 tho'?

He was a 6 up until the last 15 mins!!

Funny how we all see the game different.
Thought he was superb again tonight.
Unsung hero of that side again.

Shephard is 8/9 when he's in advanced positions but I only give him a 6 when defending.

JonD wrote:Shephard is 8/9 when he's in advanced positions but I only give him a 6 when defending.

Would agree with that, however overall an improvement to the squad.

OLDCROMWELLIAN wrote:

JonD wrote:Shephard is 8/9 when he's in advanced positions but I only give him a 6 when defending.

Would agree with that, however overall an improvement to the squad.

Great addition to the squad. Have noticed that defending isnt his strength and quiet attacking threat the past few games.

Spot on I would say - good all round performance - labs needs to concentrate on standing up and keeping play going - I sense he is getting better but goes to ground too quickly.

I would question giving an 8 to Haynes who has a tendency to overhit his balls into the box and a lesser mark to Shepherd who has a tendency for a more accurate cross. Defensively there is nothing between them...